Cline
Cline
VS
Windsurf
Windsurf

Cline vs Windsurf: Which AI Agent Is Better?

An in-depth comparison of Cline and Windsurf across output quality, autonomy, reliability, speed, value, and ease of use. Vote for your favorite.

What a day with Cline or Windsurf costs

Either way, you pay for the model calls. A median coding-agent day on our gateway is 95 requests and 8.6 million tokens. The table prices every step at one model’s rate.

Cline runs on Standard Compute, where each step goes to the cheapest model that can do it: routine steps go to efficient open models, hard ones to frontier models such as Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra.

Providers
Vetted for price, uptime and speed, with automatic fallback when one fails
Compliance
Opt-in rules keep a company, team or key on European or US providers
Privacy
We don’t train on your prompts or store them
Median and 90th percentile active days of coding-agent traffic, Sep 14 to Oct 13, priced at list. Agent Burn Index
ModelTypical dayBusy day
Claude Opus 5.5$7.34$59.10
Claude Sonnet 5.5$3.67$29.55
GPT-6 Luna$0.23$2.43
Get your API key Cline setup →Cline pricing →

Fixed monthly plans from $19. Eligible new accounts can try $0.25 of compute first, no card. Trial terms

Community Vote

Pick a winner in each category. You can change your vote anytime.

Output Quality
Writes correct, production-ready code and answers
Autonomy
Completes multi-step tasks end-to-end without hand-holding
Reliability
Consistent results that don't go off the rails or break
Speed
Fast responses and quick task turnaround
Value
What you get for what you pay
Ease of Use
From install to first useful result with minimal friction
Cline
Windsurf
Category
IDE Extension
IDE / Editor
Pricing
Free (BYO API key)
Free / $20 Pro / $200 Max (as Devin Desktop)
Open Source
Yes
No
Best For
Developers who want a powerful, safety-gated agent inside the editor they already use
Developers who want an affordable AI editor with agentic capabilities
Key Features
Plan/Act approval modes, VS Code, JetBrains & CLI, MCP marketplace integration
Agentic multi-file editing, Built-in VS Code-style IDE, Terminal integration

Verdict: Cline or Windsurf?

Updated 2026-10-16

Choose Cline if you are developers who want a powerful, safety-gated agent inside the editor they already use. Choose Windsurf if you are developers who want an affordable AI editor with agentic capabilities.

In our editorial scoring, Cline leads in 4 of six categories (output quality, autonomy, reliability and value), while Windsurf leads in 2 (speed and ease of use). On price, Cline runs free (byo api key) and is open source; Windsurf runs free / $20 pro / $200 max (as devin desktop) and is proprietary.

Where Cline falls short
  • Token-hungry: BYOK costs can spike on large tasks without a flat-price plan
  • No bundled model: you must arrange model access before it does anything
Full Cline review →
Where Windsurf falls short
  • The Windsurf brand is gone: since June 2026 it ships as Devin Desktop, so docs, plans and naming are in flux
  • Smaller community and ecosystem than Cursor or Copilot
Full Windsurf review →

What it costs to run Cline

Best API for Cline →
5 options compared, with prices and limits

Found your agent? Cut what it spends on models.

Standard Compute sends each step to the cheapest model that can do it, on providers we vet for price, uptime and speed. Plans start at $19 a month, and eligible new accounts can try $0.25 of compute with no card. Choose your agent below to connect.

Cline setup guide →

See the trial and activation steps →

More on Cline: How do I use DeepSeek in Cline? · How do I use GLM 5.3 in Cline?

In-Depth Comparison

Cline Overview

Cline is the open-source coding agent that defined the in-editor agent category, with 11M+ installs across VS Code, JetBrains, Cursor, its CLI and a new desktop app. Its Plan/Act modes separate thinking from doing: the agent proposes a plan you approve before it touches files or runs commands. Apache-2.0 licensed with full bring-your-own-key model freedom, MCP integration, and deployment options up to on-prem and air-gapped for enterprises.

Windsurf Overview

Windsurf began as Codeium's AI-first code editor, known for its Cascade agent. Cognition (the company behind Devin) bought it in 2025, and since June 2026 it ships as Devin Desktop, "the next generation of Windsurf": an agent command center with a built-in VS Code-style IDE; windsurf.com now redirects there. Plans are shared with Devin: Free, Pro at $20 a month and Max at $200, each with a usage allowance that refreshes daily and weekly, and extra usage billed at API prices.

Score Breakdown

Output Quality
8.5
vs
8.0
Autonomy
8.5
vs
8.0
Reliability
8.0
vs
7.5
Speed
7.5
vs
8.5
Value
8.5
vs
7.5
Ease of Use
8.0
vs
8.5

Features

Cline
  • Plan/Act approval modes
  • VS Code, JetBrains & CLI
  • MCP marketplace integration
  • Any model (BYOK)
  • Browser & terminal tool use
  • On-prem / air-gapped options
Windsurf
  • Agentic multi-file editing
  • Built-in VS Code-style IDE
  • Terminal integration
  • Code generation
  • Autocomplete
  • Codebase search

Cline runs on Standard Compute

Standard Compute

Current frontier models Claude Fable 5.1 · GPT-6 Astra

More intelligence
per dollar.

Each step goes to the cheapest model that can do it, on providers we vet for price, uptime and speed, with automatic fallback when one fails.

Compliance
Opt-in rules keep a company, team or key on European or US providers
Privacy
We don’t train on your prompts or store them

Fixed monthly plans from $19 · cancel anytime · Cline setup →

7-day fair refund Free trial, no card Billing by Stripe3,800+ agent users

Related Comparisons

Claude CodeVSClineClaude CodeVSWindsurfClineVSHermesHermesVSWindsurfClineVSCodexCodexVSWindsurfClineVSGemini CLIGemini CLIVSWindsurf