Devin
Devin
VS
Windsurf
Windsurf

Devin vs Windsurf: Which AI Agent Is Better?

An in-depth comparison of Devin and Windsurf across output quality, autonomy, reliability, speed, value, and ease of use. Vote for your favorite.

For companies: one company account, with a key and a fixed monthly budget for every person and app.Create a company workspace → or talk to us

Community Vote

Pick a winner in each category. You can change your vote anytime.

Output Quality
Writes correct, production-ready code and answers
Autonomy
Completes multi-step tasks end-to-end without hand-holding
Reliability
Consistent results that don't go off the rails or break
Speed
Fast responses and quick task turnaround
Value
What you get for what you pay
Ease of Use
From install to first useful result with minimal friction
Devin
Windsurf
Category
Coding Agent
IDE / Editor
Pricing
Free / $20 Pro / $200 Max / Teams from $80
Free / $20 Pro / $200 Max (as Devin Desktop)
Open Source
No
No
Best For
Teams that want to delegate well-scoped engineering tickets end-to-end
Developers who want an affordable AI editor with agentic capabilities
Key Features
Fully autonomous ticket-to-PR workflow, Own cloud dev environment + browser, Parallel sessions
Agentic multi-file editing, Built-in VS Code-style IDE, Terminal integration

Verdict: Devin or Windsurf?

Updated 2026-10-16

Choose Devin if you are teams that want to delegate well-scoped engineering tickets end-to-end. Choose Windsurf if you are developers who want an affordable AI editor with agentic capabilities.

In our editorial scoring, Windsurf leads in 3 of six categories (reliability, speed and value), while Devin leads in 2 (output quality and autonomy). On price, Devin runs free / $20 pro / $200 max / teams from $80 and is proprietary; Windsurf runs free / $20 pro / $200 max (as devin desktop) and is proprietary.

Where Windsurf falls short
  • The Windsurf brand is gone: since June 2026 it ships as Devin Desktop, so docs, plans and naming are in flux
  • Smaller community and ecosystem than Cursor or Copilot
Full Windsurf review →

In-Depth Comparison

Devin Overview

Devin is Cognition's fully autonomous software engineer: give it a task in Slack, Linear, or the web IDE and it plans, writes code, runs tests, and opens a pull request in its own cloud sandbox, including several sessions in parallel. It shines on well-scoped, repetitive engineering work (migrations, test coverage, small features) and improved markedly through its 2.x releases, but it remains weaker on ambiguous, novel tasks. Self-serve plans are Free, Pro at $20 a month and Max at $200, each with a daily and weekly usage allowance and paid extra usage, so heavy use still costs real money. Cognition bought Windsurf in 2025 and now ships it as Devin Desktop, alongside a Devin CLI.

Windsurf Overview

Windsurf began as Codeium's AI-first code editor, known for its Cascade agent. Cognition (the company behind Devin) bought it in 2025, and since June 2026 it ships as Devin Desktop, "the next generation of Windsurf": an agent command center with a built-in VS Code-style IDE; windsurf.com now redirects there. Plans are shared with Devin: Free, Pro at $20 a month and Max at $200, each with a usage allowance that refreshes daily and weekly, and extra usage billed at API prices.

Score Breakdown

Output Quality
8.5
vs
8.0
Autonomy
9.5
vs
8.0
Reliability
7.0
vs
7.5
Speed
7.0
vs
8.5
Value
6.0
vs
7.5
Ease of Use
8.5
vs
8.5

Features

Devin
  • Fully autonomous ticket-to-PR workflow
  • Own cloud dev environment + browser
  • Parallel sessions
  • Slack / Linear / GitHub integration
  • Devin Desktop & CLI
  • Interactive planning mode
Windsurf
  • Agentic multi-file editing
  • Built-in VS Code-style IDE
  • Terminal integration
  • Code generation
  • Autocomplete
  • Codebase search

More intelligence per dollar.

Every agent on this page runs on Standard Compute. Each step goes to the cheapest model that can do it, on providers we vet for price, uptime and speed, with automatic fallback when one fails. Current frontier models: Claude Fable 5.2 and GPT-6 Astra. Opt-in rules keep a company, team or key on European or US providers, and we don’t train on your prompts or store them.

Get your API keySee how it works

Fixed monthly plans from $19 · cancel anytime

Related Comparisons

Claude CodeVSWindsurfClaude CodeVSDevinHermesVSWindsurfDevinVSHermesCodexVSWindsurfCodexVSDevinGemini CLIVSWindsurfDevinVSGemini CLI